ANF04. Fathers of the Third Century: Tertullian, Part Fourth; Minucius Felix; Commodian; Origen, Parts First and Second
By Ante-Nicene Fathers (Ed. Philip Schaff) · Early Church Fathers (Ante-Nicene) · 263 chapters
Table of Contents (263 Sections)
- Introductory Notice.
- Time Changes Nations
- The Law of Change, or Mutation, Universal.
- Beasts Similarly Subject to the Law of Mutation.
- Change Not Always Improvement.
- Virtues of the Mantle. It Pleads in Its Own Defence.
- Further Distinctions, and Crowning Glory, of the Pallium.
- Elucidations
- Book I
- II
- Elucidation.
- Truth Rather to Be Appealed to Than Custom, and Truth Progressive in Its Developments.
- Before Proceeding Farther, Let the Question of Custom Itself Be Sifted.
- Gradual Development of Custom, and Its Results. Passionate Appeal to Truth.
- Of the Argument Drawn from 1 Cor. XI. 5-16.
- Of the Word Woman, Especially in Connection with Its Application to Eve.
- The Parallel Case of Mary Considered.
- Of the Reasons Assigned by the Apostle for Bidding Women to Be Veiled.
- The Argument E Contrario.
- Veiling Consistent with the Other Rules of Discipline Observed by Virgins and Women in General.
- If the Female Virgins are to Be Thus Conspicuous, Why Not the Male as Well?
- The Rule of Veiling Not Applicable to Children.
- Womanhood Self-Evident, and Not to Be Concealed by Just Leaving the Head Bare.
- If Unveiling Be Proper, Why Not Practise It Always, Out of the Church as Well as in It?
- Perils to the Virgins Themselves Attendant Upon Not-Veiling.
- Of Fascination.
- Tertullian, Having Shown His Defence to Be Consistent with Scripture, Nature, and Discipline, Appeals to the Virgins Themselves.
- An Appeal to the Married Women.
- Elucidations.
- I
- Book II
- Elucidation.
- Introduction. Virginity Classified Under Three Several Species.
- The Blame of Our Misdeeds Not to Be Cast Upon God. The One Power Which Rests with Man is the Power of Volition.
- Of Indulgence and Pure Volition. The Question Illustrated.
- Further Remarks Upon the Apostle
- Unity of Marriage Taught by Its First Institution, and by the Apostle
- The Objection from the Polygamy of the Patriarchs Answered.
- Even the Old Discipline Was Not Without Precedents to Enforce Monogamy. But in This as in Other Respects, the New Has Brought in a Higher Perfection.
- If It Be Granted that Second Marriage is Lawful, Yet All Things Lawful are Not Expedient.
- Second Marriage a Species of Adultery, Marriage Itself Impugned, as Akin to Adultery.
- Application of the Subject. Advantages of Widowhood.
- The More the Wives, the Greater the Distraction of the Spirit.
- Excuses Commonly Urged in Defence of Second Marriage. Their Futility, Especially in the Case of Christians, Pointed Out.
- Examples from Among the Heathen, as Well as from the Church, to Enforce the Foregoing Exhortation.
- Elucidation.
- Different Views in Regard to Marriage Held by Heretics, Psychic, and Spiritualists.
- The Spiritualists Vindicated from the Charge of Novelty.
- The Question of Novelty Further Considered in Connection with the Words of the Lord and His Apostles.
- Waiving Allusion to the Paraclete, Tertullian Comes to the Consideration of the Ancient Scriptures, and Their Testimony on the Subject in Hand.
- Connection of These Primeval Testimonies with Christ.
- The Case of Abraham, and Its Bearing on the Present Question.
- From Patriarchal, Tertullian Comes to Legal, Precedents.
- From the Law Tertullian Comes to the Gospel. He Begins with Examples Before Proceeding to Dogmas.
- From Examples Tertullian Passes to Direct Dogmatic Teachings. He Begins with the Lord
- St. Paul
- Further Remarks Upon St. Paul
- The Explanation of the Passage Offered by the Psychics Considered.
- Further Objections from St. Paul Answered.
- Even If the Permission Had Been Given by St. Paul in the Sense Which the Psychics Allege, It Was Merely Like the Mosaic Permission of Divorce--A Condescension to Human Hard-Heartedness.
- Unfairness of Charging the Disciples of the New Prophecy with Harshness. The Charge Rather to Be Retorted Upon the Psychics.
- Weakness of the Pleas Urged in Defence of Second Marriage.
- Heathen Examples Cry Shame Upon This “Infirmity of the Flesh.”
- Elucidations.
- Chapter I
- God Just as Well as Merciful; Accordingly, Mercy Must Not Be Indiscriminate.
- An Objection Anticipated Before the Discussion Above Promised is Commenced.
- Adultery and Fornication Synonymous.
- Of the Prohibition of Adultery in the Decalogue.
- Examples of Such Offences Under the Old Dispensation No Pattern for the Disciples of the New. But Even the Old Has Examples of Vengeance Upon Such Offences.
- Of the Parables of the Lost Ewe and the Lost Drachma.
- Of the Prodigal Son.
- Certain General Principles of Parabolic Interpretation. These Applied to the Parables Now Under Consideration, Especially to that of the Prodigal Son.
- Repentance More Competent to Heathens Than to Christians.
- From Parables Tertullian Comes to Consider Definite Acts of the Lord.
- Of the Verdict of the Apostles, Assembled in Council, Upon the Subject of Adultery.
- Of St. Paul, and the Person Whom He Urges the Corinthians to Forgive.
- The Same Subject Continued.
- The Same Subject Continued.
- General Consistency of the Apostle.
- Consistency of the Apostle in His Other Epistles.
- Answer to a Psychical Objection.
- Objections from the Revelation and the First Epistle of St. John Refuted.
- From Apostolic Teaching Tertullian Turns to that of Companions of the Apostles, and of the Law.
- Of the Difference Between Discipline and Power, and of the Power of the Keys.
- Of Martyrs, and Their Intercession on Behalf of Scandalous Offenders.
- Elucidations.
- Connection of Gluttony and Lust. Grounds of Psychical Objections Against the Montanists.
- Arguments of the Psychics, Drawn from the Law, the Gospel, the Acts, the Epistles, and Heathenish Practices.
- The Principle of Fasting Traced Back to Its Earliest Source.
- The Objection is Raised, Why, Then, Was the Limit of Lawful Food Extended After the Flood? The Answer to It.
- Proceeding to the History of Israel, Tertullian Shows that Appetite Was as Conspicuous Among Their Sins as in Adam
- The Physical Tendencies of Fasting and Feeding Considered. The Cases of Moses and Elijah.
- Further Examples from the Old Testament in Favour of Fasting.
- Examples of a Similar Kind from the New.
- From Fasts Absolute Tertullian Comes to Partial Ones and Xerophagies.
- Of Stations, and of the Hours of Prayer.
- Of the Respect Due to “Human Authority;” And of the Charges of “Heresy” And “Pseudo-Prophecy.”
- Of the Need for Some Protest Against the Psychics and Their Self-Indulgence.
- Of the Inconsistencies of the Psychics.
- Reply to the Charge of “Galaticism.“
- Of the Apostle
- Instances from Scripture of Divine Judgments Upon the Self-Indulgent; And Appeals to the Practices of Heathens.
- Conclusion.
- Elucidations.
- De Fuga in Persecutione.
- Elucidations.
- A Strain of Jonah the Prophet.
- A Strain of Sodom.
- Genesis.
- A Strain of the Judgment of the Lord.
- Five Books in Reply to Marcion.
- Elucidations.
- Introductory Note.
- Argument: Minucius Relates How Delightful to Him is the Recollection of the Things that Had Happened to Him with Octavius While He Was Associated with Him at Rome, and Especially of This Disputation.
- Argument: The Arrival of Octavius at Rome During the Time of the Public Holidays Was Very Agreeable to Minucius. Both of Them Were Desirous of Going to the Marine Baths of Ostia, with Cæcilius Associated with Them as a Companion of Minucius. On Their Way Together to the Sea, Cæcillus, Seeing an Image of Serapis, Raises His Hand to His Mouth, and Worships It.
- Argument: Octavius, Displeased at the Act of This Superstitious Man, Sharply Reproaches Minucius, on the Ground that the Disgrace of This Wicked Deed is Reflected Not Less on Himself, as Cæcilius
- Argument: Cæcilius, Somewhat Grieved at This Kind of Rebuke Which for His Sake Minucius Had Had to Bear from Octavius, Begs to Argue with Octavius on the Truth of His Religion. Octavius with His Companion Consents, and Minucius Sits in the Middle Between Cæcilius and Octavius.
- Argument: Cæcilius Begins His Argument First of All by Reminding Them that in Human Affairs All Things are Doubtful and Uncertain, and that Therefore It is to Be Lamented that Christians, Who for the Most Part are Untrained and Illiterate Persons, Should Dare to Determine on Anything with Certainty Concerning the Chief of Things and the Divine Majesty: Hence He Argues that the World is Governed by No Providence, and Concludes that It is Better to Abide by the Received Forms of Religion.
- Argument: The Object of All Nations, and Especially of the Romans, in Worshipping Their Divinities, Has Been to Attain for Their Worship the Supreme Dominion Over the Whole Earth.
- Argument: That the Roman Auspices and Auguries Have Been Neglected with Ill Consequences, But Have Been Observed with Good Fortune.
- Argument: The Impious Temerity of Theodorus, Diagoras, and Protagoras is Not at All to Be Acquiesced In, Who Wished Either Altogether to Get Rid of the Religion of the Gods, or at Least to Weaken It. But Infinitely Less to Be Endured is that Skulking and Light-Shunning People of the Christians, Who Reject the Gods, and Who, Fearing to Die After Death, Do Not in the Meantime Fear to Die.
- Argument: The Religion of the Christians is Foolish, Inasmuch as They Worship a Crucified Man, and Even the Instrument Itself of His Punishment. They are Said to Worship the Head of an Ass, and Even the Nature of Their Father. They are Initiated by the Slaughter and the Blood of an Infant, and in Shameless Darkness They are All Mixed Up in an Uncertain Medley.
- Argument: Whatever the Christians Worship, They Strive in Every Way to Conceal: They Have No Altars, No Temples, No Acknowledged Images. Their God, Like that of the Jews, is Said to Be One, Whom, Although They are Neither Able to See Nor to Show, They Think Nevertheless to Be Mischievous, Restless, and Unseasonably Inquisitive.
- Argument: Besides Asserting the Future Conflagration of the Whole World, They Promise Afterwards the Resurrection of Our Bodies: and to the Righteous an Eternity of Most Blessed Life; To the Unrighteous, of Extreme Punishment.
- Argument: Moreover, What Will Happen to the Christians Themselves After Death, May Be Anticipated from the Fact that Even Now They are Destitute of All Means, and are Afflicted with the Heaviest Calamities and Miseries.
- Argument: Cæcilius at Length Concludes that the New Religion is to Be Repudiated; And that We Must Not Rashly Pronounce Upon Doubtful Matters.
- Argument: With Something of the Pride of Self-Satisfaction, Cæcilius Urges Octavius to Reply to His Arguments; And Minucius with Modesty Answers Him, that He Must Not Exult at His Own by No Means Ordinary Eloquence, and at the Harmonious Variety of His Address.
- Argument: Cæcilius Retorts Upon Minucius, with Some Little Appearance of Being Hurt, that He is Foregoing the Office of a Religious Umpire, When He is Weakening the Force of His Argument. He Says that It Should Be Left to Octavius to Confute All that He Had Advanced.
- Argument: Octavius Arranges His Reply, and Trusts that He Shall Be Able to Dilute the Bitterness of Reproach with the River of Truthful Words. He Proceeds to Weaken the Individual Arguments of Cæcilius. Nobody Need Complain that the Christians, Unlearned Though They May Be, Dispute About Heavenly Things Because It is Not the Authority of Him Who Argues, But the Truth of the Argument Itself, that Should Be Considered.
- Argument: Man Ought Indeed to Know Himself, But This Knowledge Cannot Be Attained by Him Unless He First of All Acknowledges the Entire Scope of Things, and God Himself. And from the Constitution and Furniture of the World Itself, Every One Endowed with Reason Holds that It Was Established by God, and is Governed and Administered by Him.
- Argument: Moreover, God Not Only Takes Care of the Universal World, But of Its Individual Parts. That by the Decree of the One God All Things are Governed, is Proved by the Illustration of Earthly Empires. But Although He, Being Infinite and Immense--And How Great He Is, is Known to Himself Alone--Cannot Either Be Seen or Named by Us, Yet His Glory is Beheld Most Clearly When the Use of All Titles is Laid Aside.
- Argument: Moreover, the Poets Have Called Him the Parent of Gods and Men, the Creator of All Things, and Their Mind and Spirit. And, Besides, Even the More Excellent Philosophers Have Come Almost to the Same Conclusion as the Christians About the Unity of God.
- Argument: But If the World is Ruled by Providence and Governed by the Will of One God, an Ignorant Antipathy Ought Not to Carry Us Away into the Error of Agreement with It: Although Delighted with Its Own Fables, It Has Brought in Ridiculous Traditions. Nor is It Shown Less Plainly that the Worship of the Gods Has Always Been Silly and Impious, in that the Most Ancient of Men Have Venerated Their Kings, Their Illustrious Generals, and Inventors of Arts, on Account of Their Remarkable Deeds, No Otherwise Than as Gods.
- Argument: Octavius Attests the Fact that Men Were Adopted as Gods, by the Testimony of Euhemerus, Prodicus, Persæus, and Alexander the Great, Who Enumerate the Country, the Birthdays, and the Burial-Places of the Gods. Moreover He Sets Forth the Mournful Endings, Misfortunes, and Deaths of the Gods. And, in Addition, He Laughs at the Ridiculous and Disgusting Absurdities Which the Heathens Continually Allege About the Form and Appearance of Their Gods.
- Argument: Moreover, These Fables, Which at First Were Invented by Ignorant Men, Were Afterwards Celebrated by Others, and Chiefly by Poets, Who Did No Little Mischief to the Truth by Their Authority. By Fictions of This Kind, and by Falsehoods of a Yet More Attractive Nature, the Minds of Young People are Corrupted, and Thence They Miserably Grow Old in These Beliefs, Although, on the Other Hand, the Truth is Obvious to Them If They Will Only Seek After It.
- Argument: Although the Heathens Acknowledge Their Kings to Be Mortal, Yet They Feign that They are Gods Even Against Their Own Will, Not Because of Their Belief in Their Divinity, But in Honour of the Power that They Have Exerted. Yet a True God Has Neither Rising Nor Setting. Thence Octavius Criticises the Images and Shrines of the Gods.
- Argument: He Briefly Shows, Moreover, What Ridiculous, Obscene, and Cruel Rites Were Observed in Celebrating the Mysteries of Certain Gods.
- Argument: Then He Shows that Cæcilius Had Been Wrong in Asserting that the Romans Had Gained Their Power Over the Whole World by Means of the Due Observance of Superstitions of This Kind. Rather the Romans in Their Origin Were Collected by Crime, and Grew by the Terrors of Their Ferocity. And Therefore the Romans Were Not So Great Because They Were Religious, But Because They Were Sacrilegious with Impunity.
- Argument: The Weapon that Cæcilius Had Slightly Brandished Against Him, Taken from the Auspices and Auguries of Birds, Octavius Retorts by Instancing the Cases of Regulus, Mancinus, Paulus, and Cæsar. And He Shows by Other Examples, that the Argument from the Oracles is of No Greater Force Than the Others.
- Argument: Recapitulation. Doubtless Here is a Source of Error: Demons Lurk Under the Statues and Images, They Haunt the Fanes, They Animate the Fibres of the Entrails, Direct the Flights of Birds, Govern the Lots, Pour Forth Oracles Involved in False Responses. These Things Not from God; But They are Constrained to Confess When They are Adjured in the Name of the True God, and are Driven from the Possessed Bodies. Hence They Flee Hastily from the Neighbourhood of Christians, and Stir Up a Hatred Against Them in the Minds of the Gentiles Who Begin to Hate Them Before They Know Them.
- Argument: Nor is It Only Hatred that They Arouse Against the Christians, But They Charge Against Them Horrid Crimes, Which Up to This Time Have Been Proved by Nobody. This is the Work of Demons. For by Them a False Report is Both Set on Foot and Propagated. The Christians are Falsely Accused of Sacrilege, of Incest, of Adultery, of Parricide; And, Moreover, It is Certain and True that the Very Same Crimes, or Crimes Like to or Greater Than These, are in Fact Committed by the Gentiles Themselves.
- Argument: Nor is It More True that a Man Fastened to a Cross on Account of His Crimes is Worshipped by Christians, for They Believe Not Only that He Was Innocent, But with Reason that He Was God. But, on the Other Hand, the Heathens Invoke the Divine Powers of Kings Raised into Gods by Themselves; They Pray to Images, and Beseech Their Genii.
- Argument: The Story About Christians Drinking the Blood of an Infant that They Have Murdered, is a Barefaced Calumny. But the Gentiles, Both Cruelly Expose Their Children Newly Born, and Before They are Born Destroy Them by a Cruel Abortion. Christians are Neither Allowed to See Nor to Hear of Manslaughter.
- Argument: The Charge of Our Entertainments Being Polluted with Incest, is Entirely Opposed to All Probability, While It is Plain that Gentiles are Actually Guilty of Incest. The Banquets of Christians are Not Only Modest, But Temperate. In Fact, Incestuous Lust is So Unheard Of, that with Many Even the Modest Association of the Sexes Gives Rise to a Blush.
- Argument: Nor Can It Be Said that the Christians Conceal What They Worship Because They Have No Temples and No Altars, Inasmuch as They are Persuaded that God Can Be Circumscribed by No Temple, and that No Likeness of Him Can Be Made. But He is Everywhere Present, Sees All Things, Even the Most Secret Thoughts of Our Hearts; And We Live Near to Him, and in His Protection.
- Argument: That Even If God Be Said to Have Nothing Availed the Jews, Certainly the Writers of the Jewish Annals are the Most Sufficient Witnesses that They Forsook God Before They Were Forsaken by Him.
- Argument: Moreover, It is Not at All to Be Wondered at If This World is to Be Consumed by Fire, Since Everything Which Has a Beginning Has Also an End. And the Ancient Philosophers are Not Averse from the Opinion of the Probable Burning Up of the World. Yet It is Evident that God, Having Made Man from Nothing, Can Raise Him Up from Death into Life. And All Nature Suggests a Future Resurrection.
- Argument: Righteous and Pious Men Shall Be Rewarded with Never-Ending Felicity, But Unrighteous Men Shall Be Visited with Eternal Punishment. The Morals of Christians are Far More Holy Than Those of the Gentiles.
- Argument: Fate is Nothing, Except So Far as Fate is God. Man
- Argument: Tortures Most Unjustly Inflicted for the Confession of Christ
- Argument: Christians Abstain from Things Connected with Idol Sacrifices, Lest Any One Should Think Either that They Yield to Demons, or that They are Ashamed of Their Religion. They Do Not Indeed Despise All the Colour and Scent of Flowers, for They are Accustomed to Use Them Scattered About Loosely and Negligently, as Well as to Entwine Their Necks with Garlands; But to Crown the Head of a Corpse They Think Superfluous and Useless. Moreover, with the Same Tranquillity with Which They Live They Bury Their Dead, Waiting with a Very Certain Hope the Crown of Eternal Felicity. Therefore Their Religion, Rejecting All the Superstitions of the Gentiles, Should Be Adopted as True by All Men.
- Argument: When Octavius Had Finished This Address, Minucius and Cæcilius Sate for Some Time in Attentive and Silent Wonder. And Minucius Indeed Kept Silence in Admiration of Octavius, Silently Revolving What He Had Heard.
- Argument: Then Cæcilius Exclaims that He is Vanquished by Octavius; And That, Being Now Conqueror Over Error, He Professes the Christian Religion. He Postpones, However, Till the Morrow His Training in the Fuller Belief of Its Mysteries.
- Argument: Finally, All are Pleased, and Joyfully Depart: Cæcilius, that He Had Believed; Octavius, that He Had Conquered; And Minucius, that the Former Had Believed, and the Latter Had Conquered.
- Elucidations.
- Introductory Note.
- Preface.
- God
- The Worship of Demons.
- Saturn.
- Jupiter.
- Of the Same Jupiter
- Of the Septizonium and the Stars.
- Of the Sun and Moon.
- Mercury.
- Neptune.
- Apollo the Soothsaying and False.
- Father Liber--Bacchus.
- The Unconquered One.
- Sylvanus.
- Hercules.
- Of the Gods and Goddesses.
- Of Their Images.
- Of Ammydates and the Great God.
- Of the Vain Nemesiaci.
- The Titans.
- The Montesiani.
- The Dulness of the Age.
- Of Those Who are Everywhere Ready.
- Of Those Who Live Between the Two.
- They Who Fear and Will Not Believe.
- To Those Who Resist the Law of Christ the Living God.
- O Fool, Thou Dost Not Die to God.
- The Righteous Rise Again.
- To the Wicked and Unbelieving Rich Man.
- Rich Men, Be Humble.
- To Judges.
- To Self-Pleasers.
- To the Gentiles.
- Moreover, to Ignorant Gentiles.
- Of the Tree of Life and Death.
- Of the Foolishness of the Cross.
- The Fanatics Who Judaize.
- Also to the Jews.
- Again to the Same.
- Of the Time of Antichrist.
- Of the Hidden and Holy People of the Almighty Christ, the Living God.
- Of the End of This Age.
- Of the First Resurrection.
- Of the Day of Judgment.
- To Catechumens.
- To the Faithful.
- O Faithful, Beware of Evil.
- To Penitents.
- Who Have Apostatized from God.
- Of Infants.
- Deserters.
- To the Soldiers of Christ.
- Of Fugitives.
- Of the Seed of the Tares.
- To the Dissembler.
- That Worldly Things are Absolutely to Be Avoided.
- That the Christian Should Be Such.
- To the Matrons of the Church of the Living God.
- To the Same Again.
- In the Church to All the People of God.
- To Him Who Wishes for Martyrdom.
- The Daily War.
- Of the Zeal of Concupiscence.
- They Who Give from Evil.
- Of a Deceitful Peace.
- To Ministers.
- To God
- I Speak to the Elder-Born.
- To Visit the Sick.
- To the Poor in Health.
- That Sons are Not to Be Bewailed.
- Of Funeral Pomp.
- To the Clerks.
- Of Those Who Gossip, and of Silence.
- To the Drunkards.
- To the Pastors.
- The Name of the Man of Gaza.
- Elucidation.
- Preface.
- Life.
- Exegetical Works.
- Critical Works.
- Apologetical Works.
- Dogmatic Works.
- Practical Works.
- Editions of Origin.
- Prefatory Notice.
- Prologue of Rufinus.
- Preface.
- Book I
- Book II
- Book III
- IV
- Elucidations.
- A Letter to Origen from Africanus About the History of Susanna.
- A Letter from Origen to Africanus.
- A Letter from Origen to Gregory.
- Elucidation.
- I
- Book II
- Book III
- Book IV
- Book V
- Book VI
- Book VII
- Book VIII